We've just launched our new site to better serve you! Please take a look around, and leave us feedback in our exit survey after checkout!





We have been selling cards online since 1999.  This is our site,  where you can view most of our inventory.  We strive to keep our inventory full of the cards that you need,  because of this we are always looking to buy cards as well as sell them.  

We carry Magic: the Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh and Pokemon  as well as board games and a limited selection of other card games.  We also have a large selection of gaming supplies,  from dice to deck protectors to binders and deck boxes.


You can place orders here for delivery,  or to be picked up at our physical store.  Orders for pick-up must be placed on the day before pick-up to guarantee that it is ready when you arrive.  We will do our best to accomodate same day orders,  but cannot always guarantee them.

As an Authorized Internet Retailer of Wizards of the Coast, we may only ship sealed Magic: the Gathering products within the United States.

As an Authorized Internet Retailer of Wizards of the Coast, we cannot sell current sealed Magic: the Gathering products business to business.



How did you come up with the name?


People often ask me how we came up with the name "Pink Bunny Games".  It is a long story, but here it is.

This story is really a two parter.  The first part, I used to be what you would call a backpack dealer of Magic cards. This means that I would travel to events all around the midwest and trade cards for a profit with people at those events.  There were several other people that did the same thing as myself, and we all sort of hung out with each other at the events.  

The next part had really nothing to do with my Magic dealings.  My girlfriend Ericka, had ordered a coat online.  When the coat arrived, it did not look like the picture on the internet.  The one that arrived was shaped like a big square, while the one pictured online was shaped like a woman. She was going to send it back, but I asked how much it cost her.  It was only $20, so I told her to keep it and I would wear it.  The coat in question was a fluffy, furry Pink coat.

Now back to my side gig as a backpack dealer.  Magic was almost all males at the time, it is still a lot more males than females now, but we are moving in the right direction.  Back then however, a room with 1000+ Magic players likely had less than 10 women in its population.  Back then, I started wearing this fluffy Pink coat.  I was just wearing it to be that goofy guy that did abnormal stuff, but what I didn't realize, was that I was creating a brand.  When a player walked into that room with 1000 people in it and had to find one of us backpack dealers to get that last card for his deck,  I stood out like a sore thumb.  It was fairly easy to pick out the fluffy Pink coat in a room full of guys. 

All of the backpack dealers had nicknames for each other,  and mine was Pink Bunny, due to my coat resembling the energizer bunny.  I wore that coat for several years before it had to be retired, but the nickname has been with me ever since.

Fast forward a few years, and I had made the decision to open a store, rather than continue working out of my apartment.  When decidinbg what to name the store,  I made the decision that a descriptive name was not as good as a memorable name.  I could have been Game Store, or Game Emporium,  but if you looked at a list of generic sounding names, mine would dissappear into the mix as soon as you got to the next page,  however,  a name like Pink Bunny Games would stick with you,  it would stand out,  much like the fluffy Pink coat did for me so long ago.

There you have it.  That is the story of how I picked the name for the business. 









Pink Bunny Games, located in South Milwaukee Wisconsin, is a game store that specializes in Magic: the Gathering.  We have been in the business of selling Magic cards online since 1999.  We have vendor tables at many major Magic events around the country,  including Grand Prixes,  Gencon,  SCG Opens, TCGPlayer.com 5ks and other similar events.


Our store opened on April 12th, 2012.  We run events on most days throughout the week.  Many Magic events, some Yu-Gi-Oh and some board gaming events as well.


We have 2 goals at Pink Bunny Games,  

First to provide a great place for gamers of all types to come and have fun.

Second to provide a great selection of single cards to help your deck achieve its full potential!


We are open 7 days a week,  and have space for over 40 players to comfortably play games at all times!


We have an incredibly knowledgeable staff that can help you with almost anything you need,  and  have the largest selection of Magic singles in the Milwaukee area.




Never Stop Playing

Above all else,  we want you to have fun,  whether it is at our store,  or at your kitchen table.  We hope that we can help you have a great time playing games!


Pink Bunny Games

1204 Minnesota Ave

South Milwaukee,  WI 53172 U S A

See our store HERE!


Monday: 12-8
Tuesday: 12-8
Wednesday: 12-8
Thursday: 12-8
Friday: 12-8
Sat: 12-8
Sun: 12-8


Phone Number

(414) 304-5305


Contact us









Contact Us

Location - US
1204 Minnesota Ave Front , South Milwaukee, WI 53172-2026
View the map